We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Short answer
The HOTOR 2-gallon is the best car trash can for most drivers. See the HOTOR 2-gallon at Amazon.
The best car trash can for most drivers is the HOTOR 2-gallon. It’s Car and Driver’s Best Overall pick, a Wirecutter staff favorite, and the can CNN Underscored filled with water without a single drop coming through. It straps to a headrest or the back of the center console.
If you want a can that keeps its shape and has a liner you can lift out and rinse, get the Lusso Gear Spill-Proof. If you want an open-top bin the driver can toss into one-handed, the Carbage Can clips to the floor, but only if you have a flat floor mat; it doesn’t work with molded all-weather liners.
We did not test these cans ourselves. We compiled hands-on results from Car and Driver, CNN Underscored, Wirecutter and Automoblog, plus Popular Mechanics’ roundup.
Jump to: Our picks · Leakproof? · Where to mount it · How we chose · FAQ
Which one should you pick?
- Get the HOTOR 2-gallon for most drivers, or the Lusso Gear Spill-Proof if you want a liner you can lift out and rinse and it fits your seat back.
- Get the Carbage Can if you want a one-handed toss and have a flat floor mat; skip it if you have molded all-weather liners and get the HOTOR instead.
- Full breakdown below
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Best car trash can picks at a glance
- Best overall: HOTOR Car Trash Can, 2-Gallon, check the current price at Amazon
- Easiest to clean: Lusso Gear Spill-Proof Car Trash Can, 2.5 gallons, check the current price at Amazon
- Best floor bin: Carbage Can Premium, check the current price at Amazon
Check the current price at Amazon. Prices change often. The HOTOR link is the 2-gallon black version Car and Driver tested, and the Lusso Gear link opens the gray 2.5-gallon version.
| HOTOR 2-Gallon | Lusso Gear Spill-Proof | Carbage Can Premium | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Soft hanging bin with lid | Structured fabric bin with flip lid | Rigid open-top floor bin |
| Capacity | 2.0 gal measured (Car and Driver) | 2.5 gal (maker) | 2.0 gal (Car and Driver) |
| Leakproofing | Waterproof lining; water-tested by Car and Driver and CNN | Removable leakproof liner | Hard plastic shell |
| Mounting | Strap: headrest or console | Strap: headrest, console, door or glove box | Floor-mat clip (not for molded liners) |
| Bag holder | 4 magnetic snaps | Hooks for your own bags | Elastic band |
| Warranty | 24 months (authorized sellers) | Lifetime | None found |
1. HOTOR 2-Gallon: the best car trash can for most drivers
Why we picked it
Three outlets back the HOTOR from their own testing or use, and two ran their own water tests. Popular Mechanics also picks it, based on its sister site Car and Driver’s testing:
- Car and Driver (May 2026) named it Best Overall after measuring volume and filling every can with water: “We can confirm the bag will keep liquids inside, even after extended periods.”
- CNN Underscored (July 2026) “poured water straight into it… Not a single drop came through.”
- Wirecutter (April 2026) calls it “a well-constructed, thoughtfully designed receptacle,” and two of its writers use it in their own cars.
- Popular Mechanics named it Best Overall in 2024, based on Car and Driver’s testing rather than its own.
Key specs
- 2 gallons (Car and Driver measured 2.0); a 3-gallon size is also sold
- Waterproof, leakproof inner lining
- Lid with push-through rubber flaps plus a zipper
- 4 magnetic snaps hold the bag in place
- Adjustable buckle strap for a headrest or center console
- Plastic stiffeners slide in to give it shape (CNN)
- Three mesh outside pockets
Pros
- Passed two independent water tests
- Magnetic snaps that are “more than strong enough to keep the liner in place” (Car and Driver)
- Lid keeps trash out of sight
Cons
- “Not as rigid as other options” (Car and Driver); Popular Mechanics calls it “unstructured”
- Open lid flaps mean it can still spill if a full can tips or you lift it out carelessly (CNN)
Who it’s for
Most drivers and families, especially if back-seat passengers or the driver need to reach it from the back of the console.
What testers report
A Wirecutter writer found the straps “slid loose” when he looped them around the whole center console. Closing the console lid on the straps held them, though Wirecutter says that “might make the console harder (but not impossible) to close.”
Warranty
24 months from purchase from an authorized seller, plus a 30-day money-back guarantee, per HOTOR.
Price and where to buy
Check the current price at Amazon (sold by HOTOR). Choose the 2-gallon size.
2. Lusso Gear Spill-Proof: easiest to clean
Why we picked it
The Lusso Gear is the only pick with a liner you lift out and rinse instead of washing the whole bin, and it holds its shape instead of slumping. Automoblog named it Best Car Trash Can after its hands-on test in 2025, praising “the most premium construction,” and Popular Mechanics called it the easiest to clean. Car and Driver didn’t test it.
Key specs
- 2.5 gallons; waterproof Oxford fabric
- Removable leakproof liner
- Flip-top lid that zips
- Hooks to hold your own disposable bags
- Two mesh pockets and one zippered pocket
- Adjustable strap for a headrest, console, door or glove box, plus optional Velcro (Automoblog)
Pros
- Lift-out liner makes cleaning easy
- Structured shape stays open
- Most mounting options of our picks
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- “Too large for some center consoles” (Popular Mechanics)
- Lid has to be unzipped and zipped each time (Popular Mechanics)
- Pockets “aren’t as robust” (Automoblog)
- Not in Car and Driver’s water test
Who it’s for
Families with kids and anyone who tosses sticky or wet trash and wants to rinse the liner.
What testers report
Size is the main issue. Automoblog quotes an owner who found it “too large and flat to fit on the back [of] my front seats” in a Volvo SUV. Measure the back of your seat or console before you buy.
Warranty
Lifetime warranty. Lusso Gear says, “If you are unhappy with it for any reason, you may return it for an exchange or refund.”
Price and where to buy
Check the current price at Amazon (sold by Lusso Gear). The link opens the gray version; pick black on the listing if you prefer.
Where to buy: Check price at Amazon · Check price at Lusso Gear
3. Carbage Can Premium: best floor bin
Why we picked it
It’s the only pick with no lid, flap or zipper, so the driver can drop trash in one-handed. Car and Driver tested it and called it a “high-quality, made-in-America option… you’ll be hard-pressed to find a better solution.” Popular Mechanics named it Best Open Top, and Automoblog named it Best Floor-Mounted.
Three things to know before you buy. First, capacity: Car and Driver lists it at 2.0 gallons and says it’s meant for a standard two-gallon liner. Second, the Amazon listing we checked was sold and shipped by a third-party seller, not Carbage Can or Amazon, so check the seller and return terms. Third, the listing’s title is now a generic “Car Trash Can, Leakproof Auto Garbage Bin with Stability Mat Clip,” though it still names Carbage Can as the brand, and Carbage Can’s own website wasn’t working when we checked.
Key specs
- Rigid open-top plastic bin
- 2.0 gallons (Car and Driver)
- 10 x 5 x 10 in
- Floor-mat clip: one end slides into the bin, the other goes under your floor mat
- Elastic band holds a grocery bag open (“a plastic grocery bag did just fine for us,” Car and Driver)
Pros
- Fastest one-handed toss
- Hard shell can’t leak
- Uses free grocery bags
Cons
- “Stability depends on your floor mats” (Car and Driver)
- “Rather large” (Car and Driver)
- Popular Mechanics warns that “if your mats have a lip or raised edge the clip may not fit,” so molded liners with tall edges may not work
- No lid (Automoblog)
- Sold by a third-party seller on Amazon when we checked
Who it’s for
Drivers with flat carpet or rubber mats who want the quickest place to drop trash.
Who should skip it: anyone with molded all-weather liners like the WeatherTech, Husky and SMARTLINER liners in our best floor liners guide. The clip needs a flat mat to slide under.
What testers report
Car and Driver and Popular Mechanics both say its stability depends on the mat. With a light mat or a raised liner edge, it can tip.
Warranty
We found no stated warranty. The brand’s website currently redirects to a parked page.
Price and where to buy
Check the current price at Amazon, and check who the seller is before you buy.
Other options
We couldn’t confirm Amazon listings for these, so we’re not linking them:
- OUDEW cupholder can with lid: Car and Driver’s Best Cupholder Can. It holds about 16 oz, so it’s best for solo commuters with receipts and wrappers. Car and Driver says the “lid can get in the way when the trash can is close to full.”
- SGLRT door-panel clip-on (2-pack): in Car and Driver’s test, which said it “can be awkward to attach to certain vehicles.” Popular Mechanics called it “Most Discrete.”
- Drive Auto Products collapsible: Popular Mechanics’ Best Large Capacity pick, in 2- and 4-gallon sizes.
- Rhino USA Spare Tire Trash Bag: Car and Driver’s pick for camping. It mounts on an exterior spare tire, and Car and Driver says, “We wouldn’t drive with it installed.”
Leakproof car trash cans: what that really means
Car and Driver filled every can it tested with water. The hard bins held, and “even the soft, fabric trash cans” held water “for at least 30 minutes without any signs of leakage.” A leakproof can has a waterproof lining, a removable liner or a hard shell.
Only the bottom and sides are leakproof, though. CNN points out that the top is still open, so a full can can spill if it tips or when you lift it out.
Where to mount a car trash can
- Back of the center console: reachable by the driver and back-seat passengers. Both Wirecutter writers hang their HOTOR here.
- Headrest: best for back-seat passengers.
- Floor-mat clip: easy for the driver, but only with a flat mat (Carbage Can).
- Cupholder: easy for the driver, but tiny (OUDEW).
- Door panel: handy, but fit depends on the vehicle (SGLRT).
Wherever it goes, put it somewhere you can reach easily, because, as Wirecutter puts it, “keeping your eyes on the road and a hand on the wheel is key.” Never put a can in the driver’s footwell, where it could slide under the pedals.
Which car trash can should you buy?
- Most drivers: the HOTOR 2-gallon.
- You want to rinse the liner and keep the shape: the Lusso Gear Spill-Proof, if it fits your seat back.
- You want a one-handed toss and have flat floor mats: the Carbage Can.
- You have molded all-weather liners: skip the Carbage Can and get the HOTOR.
For the rest of your cabin, see our best center console organizers and best car vacuums guides.
How we chose
We did not test these trash cans ourselves. Mike compared Car and Driver’s hands-on test with measured volume and a water test (May 2026), CNN Underscored’s water-pour review (July 2026), Wirecutter’s hands-on use (updated April 2026), Automoblog’s hands-on scores (2025) and Popular Mechanics’ roundup (2024). We checked each Amazon listing and each maker’s warranty page on November 17, 2026.
For our full process, see how we choose the gear we recommend.
More in this topic: Interior and comfort start-here guide.
FAQ
Can I use grocery bags as liners?
Yes. Car and Driver says, “Yes, you can use regular grocery bags or small garbage bags.” Wirecutter adds that a bag sized to the can is easier to use.
How do I stop a car trash can from tipping over?
Strap it to a headrest or the console. For floor bins, Car and Driver suggests looking for “a weighted bottom, Velcro strips, or other securing mechanisms.”
What size car trash can do I need?
Popular Mechanics suggests “at least two gallons for a family vehicle,” while an individual or couple “would only need a gallon or less.”
How do I keep it from smelling?
Don’t leave food waste in it unless you empty it often, Wirecutter says. If you toss a lot of food, Popular Mechanics suggests a smaller can so you empty it more often.
Mike is the byline for The Car Gear Guide’s research team. We read independent tests, maker specs and fit guides, then turn them into plain-English buying guides for US drivers. We don’t hand-test the products we recommend. Guides are researched and drafted with AI tools, then fact-checked and edited before they go up.